By request here are my sweaters.
Rogue is my favourite except for the damn pilling. I followed Claudia's mods to make it a cardigan. I had the zipper installed professionally because I was too chicken to do it.
Must show the hood too.
This is my horrible, no good, rotten, feltedManosRogue. Um, I think it got felted again. It might make a good donation to Dulaan.
Here's my Ribby Cardi in a state of disrepair. I've put the stitches of the roll collar onto stitch holders to wait for the zipper band. You can see it fits width-wise and the sleeve length is great. But I'm just uncomfortable wearing it as a cropped sweater.
The plan, which Holly helped me come up with, is to knit up my extra length, and magically attach it to the bottom of the sweater. This may mean mattress stitch or it may mean ripping out the cast on row and kitchenering it together. I could pick up and knit down, but the theory is that my ribbing will have a nasty off-by-one error all the way around that would be pretty noticeable.
If anyone else has tried something that worked for them, please! let me know.